When Lacy Carmichael goes to Sand Creek Dude Ranch for Christmas vacation, she expects to relax and enjoy the great outdoors. Instead, she comes face to face with two old loves. In high school, she loved Matt Cooper. In college, she loved Spence Harper. Circumstances beyond their control ended their romances, but neither forgot the other. Can their love be rekindled? Can Lacy love two men at the same time? Can two men share one woman?