[Siren LoveXtreme Special Edition: Erotic Cowboy Ménage Romance, M/F/M/M/M/M, light consensual BDSM, spanking, HEA]
Cassidy Jocks has been forced to make a choice. She either chooses Gary, Scott, Roy, and Jesse Walker or she chooses Michael Hall, the local sheriff. She can’t do it, and when she goes to tell her men that she can’t pick, they give her the best option available. She can have all of them.
Her life with her men is a dream come true. Gary is fierce and loyal. Scott is confused, but she sees the love inside of him. Roy is cheeky, and Jesse is her best friend. Michael is the dominant.
Their relationship is working well, but when a misunderstanding causes Gary and Scott to attack Michael during his time with Cassidy, she knows it’s time to leave. Cassidy stays with her sister. She learns a few facts about herself and the love she has for her five men. Will she have the strength to fight for them? Or has her change of heart come too late?
Note: There is no sexual relationship or touching for titillation between or among siblings.
A Siren Erotic Romance
Walking down the stairs, she let out a sigh of relief when she noticed her house was completely clean. Her drinking binge hadn’t caused any external problems, so a point for her. She looked out of the window at the Walkers’ house and thought about what her sister had told her. The conversation with her sister had been one of the clearer points of last night. She knew she had to tell them what she felt. Leaving them hanging like this was not fair.
She let out a grunt of annoyance at her cowardice. All of the men should have the choice of agreeing with her thoughts or telling her to go and screw it.
“Let’s get this over with,” she said to herself.
She made her way out the door and noted Michael’s truck in the back along with all the Walkers’ trucks as well. Tucking a strand of hair behind her ear, she looked at the floor as she went to the back door. Glancing through the window of the back door, she saw the kitchen was vacant. Knocking on the window, she bounced on the backs of her heels waiting for someone to answer.
Glancing up, she saw Jesse walking through the kitchen. She smiled the moment she saw him. He was adorable, and if she was honest with herself, she fell in love with him first before the rest of his brothers.
He opened the door for her. His large frame crowded the whole doorway.
“You’re finally awake,” Jesse said.
“Yeah. It was a rough night.” She felt the blush filling her cheeks when she thought about Michael and what she’d begged him to do to her last night.
“You look lovely.” Cassidy watched as he checked her out. Jesse had the ability to make her feel loved and sexy at the same time. She was conscious of her weight as she’d always been a big girl. It had taken her years to accept she would never fit into a size twelve. She was happy with her size as she enjoyed her food and didn’t want to calorie count everything she ate. She didn’t want to think about them while staring at the perfection of this buff male in front of her.
“Thank you, Jesse.”
They stared at each other in silence for several minutes. They had done this many times over the years, just sat staring. She knew how relaxed and happy he made her.
He broke the silence first. “Come in, Cassidy. We need to talk to you about something.” Jesse moved enough to let her pass. She needed to brush against him, and she forced herself to contain her gasp of pleasure as she was pressed so close against him.
She watched him close the door and felt the goose bumps erupt up her arm as he took her hand, leading her through the house to the sitting room. She stopped short when she saw Gary, Scott, Roy, and Michael already sitting, waiting.
“What’s going on?” she asked, unable to meet Michael’s eyes. Jesse led her to the sofa. She was thankful that he didn’t let her hand go. He took the seat next to her.
“Nothing is going on, Cassidy,” Gary said with a smile.
“You mean to tell me that the Walker brothers and the local sheriff were having a nice little chat on a Sunday morning?” She knew something was going on. The last time she’d seen all these men together, a fight had ensued. She refused to believe within a few weeks they were bosom buddies.
“Just fucking tell her, Gary,” Scott said. She heard the growl of anger in his voice.
“Don’t cuss,” Gary told him.
She watched the red heat of aggression fill Scott’s face. On instinct, she got up from her seat and walked toward him. “Morning, Scott,” she said. He opened his arms to receive her. She wrapped her arms around his neck, pressing her body close to his. His heart was pounding inside his chest.
“Morning, Cassidy.” She felt him inhale her scent. Cassidy refused to let go of him until he calmed down. She didn’t like the two brothers fighting.
“Are you all right?” she asked.
“Yes. Thank you,” he whispered against her ear.
Smiling, she went back to her seat between them. All five men looked at each other. None looked at her.
Staring down at her clasped fingers, she closed her eyes for a second to gain control of her emotions.
“I can’t pick,” she whispered. The words were strange to say aloud. Licking her lips, she wondered if they’d come out. The room was so still and silent. She looked up and saw the men frozen in place.
“It’s not that I don’t want to. You’re all amazing, and I would be honored to be your woman, but I can’t make this decision, and I’m asking you not to let me,” she said.
Her throat felt tight from the onslaught of emotion.
No one said anything for many minutes. She was sure they’d be able to hear a pin drop in the deathly silence. The tears filled her eyes as she thought about them rejecting her and sending her away.
She looked up as Michael knelt in front of her. His hand was on her knee. He was smiling at her.
“We don’t want you to choose,” he said.
“What?” she asked.
The journey home was a tense one. Michael and Jesse had a hand on each of her thighs. Their touch threatened to send her over the edge. She’d never known pleasure like what they were doing to her body.
In no time at all, Michael was pulling up at the ranch. Cassidy was sure he’d broken the speed limits trying to get home. Minutes later Gary’s truck pulled up.
She was escorted indoors. Jesse started kissing her and tearing at her clothes. She pulled on the buckle of his jeans. Her dress was torn from her shoulders. Her breasts spilled out of the top. Hands grabbed her, fingering her nipples. She cried out, turning around to pull Michael close to her. Michael slammed his lips down on hers. His fingers sinking in her hair and tightening the length around his fist. She gasped as he pulled on the length, breaking the kiss.
“You’re mine. You’re not in charge tonight. We are.”
“I want to see you all.” Michael took charge ordering everyone to do as he wanted.
They moved her into the sitting room. She saw them piling cushions onto the floor. Roy and Jesse were naked. Scott pulled her panties down and removed the scraps of her dress. The black stiletto heels were the only thing she had left.
“She’s fucking beautiful.”
Michael grabbed her ass and thrust his pelvis against her stomach. “Get naked. I want to see you all.”
She left the men who were dressed and wandered over to Roy and Jesse. Cassidy glanced down and stopped in her tracks. She was no virgin, but she’d never seen cocks like the size of the ones Roy and Jesse were sporting.
“You like?” Roy asked.
“I’ve never seen anything so big.”
“I think we’re all going to get along,” Scott said from behind her. He pulled her hair aside, kissing her neck.
“How are we going to do this?” Michael asked.
“No plans, just let everything come naturally,” Cassidy said. All of them were naked. She stood and turned in a circle to stare at all of them. Her pussy throbbed from the sight of five sexy, hard-muscled, hard-shafted men.
Jesse grabbed her from behind and lifted her breasts to the men in front of her. “Who’s going to have the first taste of these tits?” he asked.
Scott moved forward. He cupped her cheek, grazing her lips with his. Seconds later, his hot mouth sucked her nipples. She cried out as the pleasure-pain of what he was doing sent goose bumps erupting all over her flesh. Cassidy closed her eyes. She couldn’t stop the intense sensation of what they were doing. She felt like a wanton hussy.
Her legs were spread and two fingers slid between her folds. Opening her eyes, she gazed down to see Roy between her legs. She cried out. Gazing past Scott, she saw Michael and Gary sat in a chair, watching her and palming their large shafts. Their pre-cum glistened in the small light provided by the lamp. Someone must have turned out the main light. The setting was perfect for fucking. She licked her lips which made both of them moan.
“I want to feel your lips around my dick,” Michael said.
All three men let her go. She walked over to Michael and knelt at his feet. He ran his fingers through her hair. His touch calmed her.
“You’re so beautiful.”
She took his cock in her hand, feeling the heat through her palm. Opening her lips, she consumed the head, licking off the jewel of semen that had gathered. She moaned as the explosion of his musky taste filled her mouth. Michael was big, perfect, and tasted even better.
“Fuck me, that looks good,” Roy said with a growl.
“She’s got the sweetest mouth. I don’t know if I’m going to last.”
“Do you think she’ll swallow?” Gary asked.
Their conversation made her so horny. They were talking about her, and the need sounding in their voice turned her tummy over.
Michael grabbed a fistful of her hair and began to control her thrusts. She held his dick at the base and took him deeper in her mouth.
“Come on, baby. You can take a little bit more,” Michael encouraged her. Cassidy relaxed and worked more of his length inside her. “That’s it. Take it all. Make your master proud.”
His words sent a frisson of excitement through her. He was her master, and she his willing slave. She moved her hand away and took all of him to the back of her throat. It took some time for her to swallow past the gagging reflex, but with his soothing words, she sucked him in like a lollipop.