Richard stared at his boyfriend in disbelief. He was sorely tempted to dig his ears to make sure he had not misheard anything.
“Babe, care to repeat that?”
“What are your thoughts about polygamous relationships?”
“Level with me, love. Do you like Sam?”
“Do you like Sam?”
“I…yes, I like Sam. He’s a friend. Is this about the shower incident?”
“Not totally. Do you like Sam enough to date him?”
“Ed, what are you trying to imply?” he countered in annoyance.
“It’s not a difficult question, love. Do you like Sam enough to date him?”
“I…yes! Okay? Satisfied?” he half shouted.
They just finished dinner a few minutes ago, so they were still sitting across from each other at the dining table. They had been discussing the progress of the renovation at the bakery initially. Suddenly, his lover had changed the topic to something unexpected. It had come out of nowhere, and he was completely shocked when Edward had mentioned it.
“Love, listen to me. Sam is attracted to both of us. You like him enough to go out on a date with him. I can honestly say that I feel the same way about him. Dating him won’t be a hardship.”
“Get to the point, babe.”
“I think we should try dating one another.”
“A polygamous relationship.”
“That’s not…whatever. Look, do you want to do this or not?”
“What brings this up?”
“Rich, the three of us have been dating one another unofficially for a while now. Do you not realize that we’ve been meeting up regularly and exclusively? We’ve barely hung out with our other friends recently.”
“I…that’s…damn it. You’re right,” Richard hissed out before glaring at his lover. “Don’t smirk and don’t give me that smug face.”
“I absolutely love it when I’m right.”
“That’s your worst personality trait right there.”
“Whatever, love. You love me in spite of it. So?”
“Don’t play coy with me, love. It’s not cute.”
“Whatever. I’m in, but only if Sam agrees to it.”
“Oh, believe me. I’m certain that he will be jumping at the chance to date us both.”
“Nope, just an educated guess. Besides, I can also be observant at certain times and I’m right more often than not.”
Richard rolled his eyes at his lover and stood up, refusing to dignify his lover’s assertion with a vocal response. Instead, he carried the dirty dishes into the kitchen. He would wash everything up because Edward had cooked the food for the two of them. It was a system that had worked for them over the years. He idly wondered what it would be like to add Sam into the mix. He had the feeling that things were about to become so much more interesting.
* * * *
Edward waited patiently for the news to sink in. Richard remained quiet next to him while Sam was staring at them both like they were insane.
“Do you want to repeat that?”
He could not help his laughter. Sam’s expression was similar to Richard’s when he had this exact same discussion with his boyfriend about being in a polygamous relationship a few days ago. Now they were here, sitting at an Italian restaurant and having lunch together on a windy Saturday. The weather was getting colder because it was already halfway through November.
“Sorry, Sam. Richard had the same reaction when the two of us were talking about this possibility.”
“Look, Sam. Can you think about it?”
“I don’t have to. It’s not a secret that I’m attracted to both of you, but…”
“But?” Richard interjected.
“What if things don’t work out? I don’t want to lose you both. You are my friends first and foremost. Your friendship is important to me.”
“It won’t be easy, Sam,” Edward admitted. “But don’t you think that we all deserve a chance to try it out?”
“Yeah, I guess.”
“Are we really doing this?” Richard chimed in again.
“It’s my idea, so I’m all for it. It’s now up to the two of you,” he responded quickly.
“I’m in if you’re both cool with it,” Sam replied hesitantly.
“Count me in,” Richard muttered eventually. “Besides, as Edward pointed out to me, the three of us had been unofficially dating one another for a few weeks now.”
Sam looked surprised upon hearing that, but the other man nodded in agreement nonetheless, realizing the truth in that statement.
“Anyway, guys. The bakery will be closed temporarily beginning next Monday. The sign has been hanging by the door for a few days now, so most of our regulars should be aware of this,” Edward announced to the other two men, effectively changing the topic before things could become awkward.
“I’ve heard back from the publisher again. The official release date for my first book will be on November twenty-fifth,” Sam followed up with his own exciting news. “Also, some people out there have apparently been intrigued enough by my book after reading the excerpts, so the publisher is planning to offer a bigger discount for the early birds.”
“That’s wonderful news, Sam,” Richard commented enthusiastically. “Congratulations.”
“It’s not much,” Sam replied with a blush.
“Baby steps, Sam,” he assured the other man kindly.
The three of them continued to chat and eat for the next hour or so before paying for their food and leaving the restaurant. They promised to meet up the next day for their first official date before going on their separate ways. Edward was a little nervous, but they could not be certain if they did not even try to date one another. He just hoped that things would work out for all three of them. Changing the nature of their relationship was a huge step and an even bigger risk after all.
Edward inhaled deeply, feeling slightly disoriented as he was opening his eyes. It was really warm. He blinked a few more times to adjust his eyesight to the morning light that streamed through the gaps in the curtains. A few seconds later, he almost snickered aloud at the erections that were poking him from the front and back. He could feel that both Richard and Sam were sporting morning woods.
He started giggling a little bit louder when both men began to rut against him in their sleep. Most people would have reacted differently. They would probably be aroused, but he found the situation hilarious instead. Sam’s cock felt huge though. He lifted the blanket and peeked at it.
“Shit,” he hissed under his breath.
He had always thought that Richard was very well-endowed, but Sam seemed to be of a similar size. He could feel his own cock growing harder at the delicious sight. He moaned softly and rubbed himself harder against Sam. His action simultaneously increased the friction on his back where Richard was still rutting against him.
“Babe,” Richard whispered in his ear.
Apparently, his boyfriend was now awake, so he did not care to restrain himself. Besides, he was really turned on now. As he was grinding even harder against Sam, the other man was gradually waking up and reciprocating the action. All three of them were now rutting against one another, grunting and groaning at the pleasurable sensation.
“Ed, sweetheart, I’m close,” Sam whimpered against his mouth, so he captured the other man’s lips with his own.
Their kiss became rougher and more passionate as their climaxes approached. He could feel that Richard was clutching him even tighter and rubbing more violently against his back. Sam retaliated by pressing even closer to his front. He was now squeezed between two muscular bodies and their hard thighs were intertwined to gain more leverage as they moved even faster.
Soon, his vision whited out. He kissed Sam more brutally when they reached their orgasms almost at the same time. His own climax intensified when he could feel Richard’s cock spasming on his back and spurting out several jets of warm come repeatedly all over him. He could not stop the whimper from deep in his throat when Richard bit down on his neck.
Meanwhile, Sam’s fingers on his hips were pressing in even deeper. It was a strange feeling, being trapped between two dominant, aggressive, and possessive lovers. He was held so tightly by both of his lovers that he knew his body would show signs of bruises when they were done. By the time they separated to continue basking in their afterglow, they were all panting breathlessly.
“Wow…” He was speechless.
“I’ll second that,” Richard agreed while panting harshly next to him.
“That’s…” Sam trailed off breathlessly before continuing. “That’s incredible.”
“I agree, Sam,” Richard remarked with a chuckle before getting up and leaning over to pull Sam into a bruising kiss.
Edward could feel his cock twitching valiantly at the sight. He could see that neither man was used to being the submissive one. Hence, their tongues were now dueling and pushing against each other as they grabbed onto each other, ferociously demanding the other man to submit as they were both growling threateningly. It was insanely arousing to watch.
When he could not take it anymore, he pulled both men down onto him, and they engaged in a scorching three-way kiss. Edward whined loudly as his lovers now directed their pent-up aggression toward him. He did not mind it at all, and he could feel himself slowly hardening once again.
“Guys, fuck me! Please!” he pleaded when the sensation began to overwhelm him.
“Who—” Richard questioned, but Edward cut his boyfriend off.
“Both of you. I want you both inside me at the same time.”
“Sweetheart, you can’t take both—”
He yanked Sam’s hair roughly and jerked his head back, causing the other man to stop midsentence and emit a loud yelp instead.
“I can take you both inside me, so shut the hell up and fuck me now!” he demanded again.
He grunted when Richard abruptly thrust in two fingers into his unprepared hole.
“You like that, babe? Huh?” Richard taunted while scissoring his fingers in and out.
“More!” he commanded.
He wanted them both inside him now.
“You asked for it, sweetheart,” Sam warned him while slicking his own renewed erection.
He waited impatiently for Richard to pull his fingers out and for Sam to push into him. When Sam’s cock was completely buried deep inside him, he keened and gripped the other man’s waist. He whined lustfully when Sam began to pound into him, not even giving him time to adjust to the man’s huge erection. He loved it though and he yearned for it.
He also opened his mouth widely and pleaded with his eyes, asking for Richard to use his mouth, which his lover happily obliged to. He felt his hard cock straining even further when Sam suddenly pulled at Richard’s hard cock and swallowed it down his own throat instead. Richard’s lustful moan was music to his ears.
Just as he was getting used to the feeling of Sam hammering into his hole, he found himself being lifted as Sam was now lying on his back. He rode the other man’s cock for a few moments before his movement was halted. He keened and hissed when he felt Richard slowly pushing his thick and long cock alongside Sam’s, but smiled victoriously when both of his lovers were fully buried deep inside him. The pain-pleasure was simultaneously unexpected and very intense.