Hailey's Game (MFM)

Cattleman's Club 2

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 150,000
404 Ratings (4.6)

Editors' Pick: Outstanding Story

[#177 Siren Menage Everlasting: Erotic Cowboy Menage a Trois Romance, M/F/M, with Consensual BDSM]

Cole Jackson and Kyle Harding haven’t got any doubts that Hailey Mathews is up to something, but they ain’t worried. They have their own wicked intentions and the full confidence that one little woman doesn’t stand a chance against two Cattlemen.

Hailey has had enough. Enough of Kyle and his smooth charm. Enough of Cole and his provocations. Not about to trust that either Cattleman has any interest in her other than playing a game, Hailey decides it’s time to show them how it’s done.

However, if things don’t go the way Hailey plans, the consequences might be more than she can pay.

Note: There is no sexual relationship or touching for titillation between or among the men.

A Siren Erotic Romance

Jenny Penn is a Siren-exclusive author.

Hailey's Game (MFM)
404 Ratings (4.6)

Hailey's Game (MFM)

Cattleman's Club 2

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 150,000
404 Ratings (4.6)
In Wish List
Available formats
Cover Art by Jenny Penn
An average book
Book Two of the "Cattleman's Club" series is another find Jenny Penn creation and expands the story of a woman who was introduced significantly in Book One. Hailey is a woman who sees herself as unattractive to men, who has built almost enpenetrable walls between herself and anyone who might express an interest in her. Especially she abhors the men of the Cattleman's Club who are accurately known for their sexual excesses and who she steers clear of whenever they come near. Yet deep down, she is drawn to two men who have been constant persons in her life, if for no other reason than they drive her crazy with their verbal jabs and the insults they throw back and forth. In spite of all the negative talk and hurtful acts during their growing up years, there has always been an attraction. This is another wonderful novel from the pen of a woman who really knows how to write erotic romance fiction. The story is not a simplistic one, but is constructed with multiple characters, multiple strands of the story that are woven together skillfully. The reader will encounter numerous twists and turns, surprises at how these characters interact, and a sense of "how will this all work out?" Not only do the characters get caught up in their "journey of discovery" about themselves and one another, but the reader will also be caught up in watching these people peel away the anger and hurt of past years to discover the love that has always been there. Just one splendid read!!
Dr. J
Professional Reviews

bluesparkleanimation.gifSPARKLING DRAGON: "Cattleman's Club Bk.2 is one of the best books I've read. The scheming and rivalry between Kyle and Cole to get into Hailey's bed will keep you turning the pages as fast as you can. The most amazing sex will tantalize you and make your mouth water with need as these two men show that they know every single thing to make a woman want to melt and accept everything they can offer in and out of bed. I have never seen such hot love making scenes as Jenny Penn wrote in this story. You'll want to have your own man nearby as you read about Cole and Kyle's ultimate sexual delights with their Hailey. This story sizzles and pops with the sexual tension and action. I am addicted to the 'Cattleman's Club' books and can't wait to read more about these devilishly handsome and incredibly erotic men who find the most incredible women. Don't miss one of the best books to come along in a very long time." -- Judy King, Veiled Secrets Reviews



5 RAVEN DIVAS, RECOMMENDED READ: "It seems as though I’ve waited for Hailey’s Game forever and let me tell you, I was not disappointed. Haley’s Game is 400 pages of delicious, scrumptious, sexy, humorous bantering between three people who are definitely in love with one another. I enjoyed how Ms. Penn brought back Patton, the Davis brothers, Rachel, Adam, and Killian to join in the fun. There were times that I laughed so hard in the book that I wanted to cry at the antics Kyle, Cole, Hailey and the rest of the gang came up with to win the game, or should I say the war. The main characters as well as the secondary characters came to life for me with the turn of every page and I remembered why I enjoyed the first Cattleman’s story so much. These guys have truly become a part of my family. Ms. Penn definitely has a way with words and one hell of an imagination because the sex scenes are explosive and will leave you panting for days while begging for more all at the same time. I must admit that there were times I wouldn’t have mind switching places with Hailey. But don’t get me wrong, Ms. Hailey had a few tricks up her sleeve as well in the boudoir. She’s one feisty lady with a sexual appetite that’s more than enough to accommodate the hungry desires of two ruggedly handsome Cattlemen. I can’t wait for the next book in the series. I hope that it either involves Cole’s crazy cousins or Hailey’s dominant brothers who are back in town to stay. I must admit Ms. Penn that the country just got a little more interesting. If you’re looking for a captivating, sizzling, well-written story that will make you laugh at the characters’ antics and set your body and soul on fire from the scorching hot sex scenes, then Hailey’s Game is definitely the book to read. Bravo Ms. Penn for hitting another home run in the Cattleman’s series. I can’t wait to see what you have up your sleeve next and I’d definitely recommend this book to my friends." -- The Blackraven, Black Raven Reviews

5 STARS: "The second in Jenny Penn’s Cattleman Club,  Hailey’s Game will put a twinkle in the readers eye.  The book is filled with snappy interactions between Haley, Cole, and Kyle with Hailey often hilariously chewing out both men.  The seduction of Hailey is like trying to tame a wild horse, Jenny Penn takes you on one wild and glorious ride with her new book." -- Emily, Sensual Reads

5 DELIGHTFUL DIVAS: "Jenny Penn’s Cattlemen’s Club series continues with a bang! Hailey’s Game certainly lives up to the standard set by Patton’s Way, the first in this series, and then some. The sexual escapades are plentiful and varied...there is plenty of humor, lust, sex, plotting, fighting, jealously, anxiety and love to fill those 400 pages and then some. The plot engages from the very first page and doesn’t let go until the end of the story. I honestly didn’t want Hailey’s Game to end and I can’t wait to find out who we have in store for our next Cattlemen’s Club tale." -- Jae, Dark Diva Reviews

5 CHERRIES: "Take two arrogant, self assured, sexy cowboys and throw in one independent spitfire of a woman and its GAME ON! Have you ever read a book that had you so drawn in on page 1 that you were reading page 401 before you even realized it? If that’s your idea of great story you are going to love Jenny Penn’s second installment in the Cattlemen’s Club series, Hailey’s Game. I’m not sure what they grow in South Alabama but whatever they’re feeding the men of Pittsview makes them ALPHA male to the max! Take for instance Kyle Harding and Cole Jackson. Kyle is, and has been, in love with Hailey Matthews since high school. He’s patient, considerate and determined in his pursuit of her. Unfortunately for Kyle, his main competition and biggest threat just happens to be his “wing-man” and best friend Cole. Cole is charm magnified by 10! He also tends to speak before he thinks. Even though he wears arrogance like a mantle, I was drawn to Cole because it was obvious that his attitude was an attempt to mask some deep seated hurt. I won’t say more than that…you’ll have to read the book to hear Cole’s story and see how Hailey goes from being his nemesis to his life savior! Both men have their work cut out for them when they set their sites on taming Hailey. I have to tell you, Hailey is so neurotic she made me laugh and want to shoot her with a tranquilizer dart all at the same time. Bless her heart, but you know that says something for a story when the reader becomes emotionally invested in the story. Ms. Penn knows how to create characters that are so different and engaging from one story to the next you aren’t left with that dreaded “I’ve read this story” or “I’ve met these people” somewhere else feeling. I can only imagine the difficulty an author has in creating fresh hero and heroines especially in a series set in the same town. Ms. Penn does it well and consistently. I didn’t write my review of Hailey’s Game immediately after reading it like a good little reviewer probably should. There is so much to this book that I actually re-read it before writing. Yep, all 423 pages as well as picking up copies of Patton’s Way and Rachel’s Seduction just to get a better feel for what all was going on in Pittsview – at the same time! That was a fun discovery, realizing that all three stories coincide to make for one very exciting summer in South Alabama. Pick up a copy of Hailey’s Game and prepare yourself to be drawn into the powerfully wicked world of the Cattlemen’s Club. Where the men are men and the women play to win!" -- Honeysuckle, Whipped Cream Reviews

5 FALLEN ANGELS: "Enough is enough! Hailey Mathews is tired of being on the receiving end of Kyle Harding and Cole Jackson's devilish, wicked schemes. So she decides to give them a taste of their own medicine in executing her own devious game and by the time she is done, neither will know what hit him. Easy plan, right? Wrong! Kyle Harding and Cole Jackson are determined to have Hailey Mathews as their woman. But in order to claim her, both Kyle and Cole know that they must first break through the numerous barricades that Hailey has surrounded herself with. It soon becomes apparent that their task at hand proves to be harder said than done because not only did Hailey refuse to give in without a fight, she is clearly determined to beat them at their own game. Hailey's Game proves to be a very entertaining read. From start to finish, it is a contest of the battle of the wills. Hailey, Kyle and Cole's personalities are each distinctly dominate and neither is willing to compromise in order to reach their goal. Hailey is very self-reliant and refuses to give up control to any man. Kyle is a smooth operator determined to keep Hailey's mind, body and soul craving for his touch. On the flip side, Cole is audacious and isn't afraid to quickly bring Hailey's desires to the forefront whenever and wherever they are together. As you can imagine their sexual encounters whether as a twosome or threesome are scorching-hot, deliciously lustful and very wicked in nature. Whew! This is one tale not to be missed. Hailey's Game is book two in Jenny Penn's Cattleman's Club series and while it can be enjoyed as a standalone, I would suggest picking up book one, Patton's Way because once you meet her as Hailey's best friend, you are definitely going to want to know her story." -- Contessa, Fallen Angel Reviews

Read more



“The bedroom’s down the hall.” Hailey groaned out that encouragement.

“I don’t need a bedroom, princess. I just need to call Cole.”

“Ah!” Hailey shoved back as hard as she could, breaking his damn spell before she said something stupid. “Why you got to be like that, Kyle? Ruin my moment?”

“Because I have a compromise to offer you.” The little bastard made her feel like the mouse in a cat’s house with that smile. Hailey didn’t trust that smile.

 “An offer?”

“Something to help with them bags, princess, because, honestly, they ain’t attractive.”

She should have known. “Kyle, do you want to die today?”

“Okay, okay.” He held up his hands in defense but didn’t slink back out her door. “I was just going to suggest a porno-date night, but—”

“A porno what?” Despite her best efforts not take him seriously, that caught her off guard on the preposterous scale. Kyle proved his willingness to go extreme as he stepped back into her and growled out in that husky way he knew made her knees wobble.

“You know, a porno-date night. You dress a little slutty, come on over to the house, and Cole and I will show you what ‘just sex’ is all about.”

Just the mere idea had her heart racing, and blood flushed through her veins, warming her up for the melt down. “You’re serious.”

“Like a pitbull after his bone, princess. See, I’ve been thinking, and it isn’t right to use sex as a weapon. That’s what we’re all kind of doing and it’s hurting us all, so I say we wise up and call a temporary truce.”


“A porno-date night,” Kyle repeated.

He meant a three-way, porno-date night, but he couldn’t understand why she had to say no to his offer. Only a fool would sleep with a man she’d already set up to seduce another woman. Right? It had almost happened a week ago, but a week ago she hadn’t liked Cole, but now she kind of feared what she’d done, worried that she might end up hurting herself.

“What do you say, princess?”

Hailey’s jaw clenched because she couldn’t tell him no, even knowing Cole was setting up to betray her. “If I said yes, it would be a no-thrills kind of deal. Straight sex. None of your deviant games.”

Almost immediately his head tilted as his eyes glanced down over her shoulder. “Well, we probably should start stretching that ass. You’ll be thankful for it when Cole’s leash comes off.”

Hailey shivered at that blunt comment, but she refused to let that distract her. “I’m not just talking about that. I’m talking no ropes, no ties, no binds, no toys—”

“No toys?”

“Nothing that I don’t own.”

There came that wicked grin. “You gonna bring your collection with you?”

“Nothing beyond a dildo and lube.”

“Boy, your collection sucks.”

“I’m serious, Kyle.”

“I know and that’s what’s so depressing. You gonna tack on no form of bondage and domination of any kind and really suck the joy out of my day?”

Kyle’s laughter didn’t infect her. Hailey’s mind still stared down the realization of what she’d just agreed to. And why not? Cole might be a bastard, but that didn’t change the fact that she wanted him. What it would change was the level of his humiliation.

Hailey’s mind latched back onto the argument she sold herself on in her garage a week back. Sleeping with Cole would only add to his shame, not hers, so she might as well enjoy the ride. Especially given that Kyle had just negotiated away all the bells and whistles Cole liked to threaten her with, though one rule remained to be stated.

“And no means no.”

“Doesn’t it always?”

“There will be no more of this just kiss her and she’ll forget about that stupid objection. No means no. Got it.”

“You know, Hailey, you’re really taking all the fun out of porno-date night.”


“Fine. No means no. No bondage. No domination. Can I at least still get a blow job?”

“Sure. I can spare the five minutes. You want it now?”

The second the words broke the air, Hailey knew she’d regret them in the very near future. At least they took the smirk off Kyle’s face. Still, that comfort seemed a little hollow as he leaned in to issue only one challenge.

“Let’s see if you have the balls to show up first. Seven o’clock. ” With that he straightened up to give her a quick, almost dismissive look. “And see if you can actually find something appropriate to wear, princess.”

Read more