“You know something?” Jerry piped up in amusement when he realized something ironic. “We’ve had sex, but I don’t think Peter and I know the name of your bar.”
The three of them guffawed almost at the same time at the strangeness of the situation they were in, and it took them a while to calm down. Leonard wheezed for a few seconds longer before answering his question.
“Fame and Fortune.”
He glanced at Leonard in confusion. “What?”
“That’s the name of my bar.”
“I like it,” Peter remarked. “Anyway, do you want to spend the night?”
“Have you changed your mind about kicking me out?” Leonard teased.
“Fuck you!” Peter retorted without heat in his voice.
Leonard winked at Peter. “You already did.”
“Smartass,” Peter retaliated with. “So, staying?”
“Absolutely. I have to leave early tomorrow morning, though.”
“Huh? What’s the operational hour for the bar?” he inquired.
“Five in the afternoon until three in the morning, but I go to the gym as often as I can. I’m getting older, and I need to maintain my fitness level.”
“Use the gym here,” Peter offered. “In fact, you can quit your gym membership.”
“Is that your roundabout way of asking me to move in with you and Jerry?” Leonard joked.
Jerry noticed that Peter wasn’t laughing when he muttered out a resounding, “Yes.”
He and Leonard turned toward Peter in shock. It wasn’t that he was averse to a polygamous relationship. He believed that the kind of relationship anyone found himself or herself in was dependent upon what everyone involved in it could agree on. It didn’t matter to him if there were two or three people in the relationship as long as everyone remained communicative and cordial to one another. However, he felt that Peter was moving too fast.
He noticed that Peter’s jaw had tightened and his boyfriend’s body was tensed up. He grabbed Peter’s cheeks and kissed the man’s lips with as much passion as he could muster, breaking away only when he felt Peter relaxing somewhat. Darren always told him that Peter was too intense and broody, but he was in love with this gorgeous hunk of a man, who could be tender and sweet sometimes. Nevertheless, he understood that Peter could be awkward at times and the man’s personality might put some people off.
Then, he faced Leonard once again, worrying that Peter might have committed an irreparable damage and scared the man off for good. That would be such a waste because he was very attracted to Leonard. It was obvious to him that Peter liked Leonard just as much. Most importantly, Leonard was also infatuated with both of them. The three of them could possibly work things out in the long run and end up as boyfriends. However, Peter’s way of advancing things among the three of them could have cost them the opportunity before they even started dating.
“I…wow…” Leonard trailed off. “You’re serious, aren’t you?”
“Yes,” Peter answered. “I don’t like wasting time. The three of us like one another very much, so I don’t see the point in beating around the bush. We’re also sexually compatible. I like having you in bed with Jerry and me. I can envision the three of us spending the rest of our lives together.”
There was silence for a minute or so before Leonard burst out laughing. “You’re one crazy motherfucker, Pete. I like that.”
“So, will you move in with Jerry and me?” Peter inquired once again without any trace of humor.
Jerry observed Leonard’s expression for a moment. Then, the man beamed at them and nodded. “Fuck it! Yes! You only live once, right? Let’s move in together. I just hope that you won’t regret that decision.”
“I won’t,” Peter stated with conviction. “Once I invest in a relationship, I’m determined to see it through until the end.”
“Okay. What about you, Jer?”
“Yeah. Is it okay with you?”
“It’s not my penthouse.”
“You live here. Besides, Peter and you were together first. I’m the third party in the relationship.”
Jerry shrugged as nonchalantly as he could, avoiding looking into either of his lovers’ eyes. “I don’t mind. I like you enough. Feelings can grow.”
He thought the three of them would have plenty of fun. He would love to get fucked by both men up his ass at the same time, but he didn’t get the chance to tell the two men about his ideas. They started arguing about who got to fuck him first. The situation escalated to the point of them grappling with each other as they strained their muscles while rolling around on the floor, trying to force their opponent to submit. His initial concerns of them fighting for real disappeared when he noticed their hard cocks rubbing against each other.
He grinned and lay on top of the pillows as he watched the sexually charged, impromptu wrestling match happening in front of him. Their grunting sounds were probably a mixture of pain and pleasure as their hands gripped onto each other, pushing back and forth. He stroked his cock at the same pace of Peter and Leonard’s cocks rutting against each other. He was concentrating so much on the two men that his climax took him by surprise. He groaned out loud as his cock spurted out so much cum that he felt as if he was showering in it, especially when it drizzled down his neck and chest toward his firm stomach.
During his afterglow, he realized that the two men had stopped wrestling. Instead, they were giving him glazed looks of arousal. He winked at both of them, which brought them out of their reverie. He had to suppress his snicker when Leonard cheated and pinched Peter’s nipples as they began to rub their hard cocks against each other once again.
He heard Peter’s whimpers growing louder seconds before his boyfriend was pushed over the edge. Then, Leonard straddled Peter’s waist and jerked his cock a few times before climaxing and coating Peter’s body with more cum. He didn’t get to enjoy the sexiness of the scene for too long, though. Once Peter stopped shuddering on the ground, Leonard stood and headed toward him on the bed. He smirked and gave Leonard his most seductive smile.
“Are you clean?” he asked.
“Yeah, I get tested recently.”
“Perfect. Breed me.”
Leonard smirked at him. “You can count on that.”
He placed one pillow underneath his lower back and raised his legs up while Leonard was greasing his hard cock with lube found on top of the bedside table. He took in the sight of the man’s sweaty body and groaned out loud, both in pain and pleasure, as Leonard thrust into him and started fucking him with so much force that his head would probably hit the headboard if the man wasn’t embracing him tight enough. He even had to wrap his thighs around Leonard’s waist to hold himself in place.
His cock hardened again as Leonard pumped that thick cock into him and hit the right spot repeatedly. He closed his eyes and enjoyed the ride. Leonard was an amazing lover, growling into his right ear while pumping into his ass without mercy. His moans were silenced when Leonard’s lips pressed against his. The two of them were locked in the same position for several moments. His cock was being stimulated so much that his body tensed up a few minutes later as he trembled through another mind-blowing orgasm.
He basked in his second afterglow as Leonard continued to drive that incredible hard cock into his tight hole. Suddenly, Leonard screamed into his ear, startling him into opening his eyes. He gasped when he saw Peter above them. Judging by his boyfriend’s movement, he could tell that Leonard was being fucked from behind. Peter was like a madman possessed, snarling and grunting while fucking into Leonard’s hole.
“How do you like being my bottom bitch now? You like my huge cock inside your ass, you fucking cock slut?”
“Fuck…fuck you, bastard. I just fucked your boyfriend into his second orgasm. I’m sure he prefers a real man like me to satisfy him.”
Jerry watched in amazement as Peter snarled and hugged Leonard’s chest even tighter before thrusting even harder into the man’s hole. He could feel the secondary impact because Leonard’s cock was being pushed into him with more force than before. He noted Leonard’s furious glare due to his current submissive position. As much as Leonard attempted to break free, Peter was much stronger. After a while, Leonard changed tactics and took out his frustrations on him instead. The groaning and panting sounds of all three of them were so loud that he would have been worried if they had any next-door neighbors to be concerned about.
“Shut your fucking mouth and take my cock, boy,” Peter taunted.
“I’m not the only one. Your boyfriend is squealing like the slut he is,” Leonard retorted. “He fucking loves my cock in his ass. His tight hole is squeezing my cock. He’s a great fuck.”
The sight of the two men fucking above him, in addition to the sounds they made and the smell of their combined cum and sweat, pushed Jerry over the edge. Leonard and Peter joined him mere seconds later. Three orgasms in a row were too much even for a twenty-six-year-old man like him. He could feel his balls protesting, and the sac tightened up to the point of being a little painful. He didn’t regret the sex at all, though. It was amazing, and he wouldn’t change a thing.