Their Broken Lady (MFM)

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 42,331
29 Ratings (4.1)

[Siren Ménage Everlasting: Erotic Ménage a Trois Romance, M/F/M, HEA]

Tanner and Bryan believe in love at first sight, and Amber is it for them. She doesn’t plan on falling in love again. Her past experience with men says she is a lousy judge of character. Amber tends to go for the strong, controlling types who end up being dangerous. They can’t understand why she’s so adamant about not becoming involved with them.

When someone tries to attack her for the second time, they convince her to stay with them while she recovers and her house is repaired. This gives them the chance to charm, woo, and seduce her into going out with them. Can they change her mind about them while they have the chance?

In the meantime, someone is out to get her, and the men are bound and determined to keep her safe. The problem is that Amber is thwarting their attempts at making her theirs forever.

Note: There is no sexual relationship or touching for titillation between or among the men.

A Siren Erotic Romance


Marla Monroe is a Siren-exclusive author.

Their Broken Lady (MFM)
29 Ratings (4.1)

Their Broken Lady (MFM)

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 42,331
29 Ratings (4.1)
In Wish List
Available formats
Cover Art by Les Byerley
Fantastic book.
Barefoot Okie



Saturday afternoon Amber stepped out to cross the street when it was free of cars. She had just gotten to the middle when a car came careening down the road heading straight for her. She ran for the other side, but twisted her ankle when her heel broke. She hit the pavement hard. She braced herself for being run over by the car, but out of nowhere, someone grabbed her and dragged her out of the street. They both ended up against the curb as the car sideswiped the car next to them and kept going.

“Fuck! Are you okay?” a man’s voice asked.

She blinked her eyes, trying to make sense of what had just happened. She’d had the light to cross and there had been no traffic when she looked.

“Lady, look at me. Are you okay?”

“Y–Yes. I twisted my ankle, though. Damn high-heeled shoes.”

The man immediately began checking her over.

“Move out of the way. Let me through.” Another man that looked enough like the first one to be his brother pushed his way through the crowd of onlookers. “Bryan, man, are you okay?”

“Yeah, I’m fine, but she’s hurt,” Bryan said.

“Let’s look her over. Did anyone call the police?” he asked, looking around.

“I did,” a man said, raising his hand.

“Good. Let’s see how bad it is.” He began checking her out.

“Hey, look. I’m okay. I just twisted my ankle.” She tried to get up, but Bryan, the first man, held her down.

“My brother is a doctor. Let him check you out. You’ve got skinned knees as well as that twisted ankle.”

“Name’s Tanner Jordan,” the second man said as he checked her ankle.

“I’m Amber. I really appreciate you both, but I’m okay.”

“Did you recognize that car?” Bryan asked.

“Huh? Why would I know that car?” she asked.

“Because whoever was driving it was obviously after you. He pulled out when you started across the road and headed straight for you.” Bryan took a cloth from someone and began to clean her knees.

Amber winced, but refrained from saying anything about the pain.

“Surely he was just some drunk driver. I can’t imagine why anyone would want to run me over.”

“You can’t think of anyone who doesn’t like you?” Tanner asked.

“Not enough to want to hit me with a car.”

A police car pulled up alongside the damaged car. The officer got out, adjusting his utility belt as he did. Amber hated getting the police involved. She had dealt with enough of them in the past.

“Hey there, Tanner, Bryan. What are you two doing here?” Officer McKenny asked.

Amber knew him from the night she had called in a possible burglar at her house. She had just gone to bed when someone began jimmying her bedroom window. She had shouted that she was calling the police, and then did. The would-be intruder had left by the time the policeman showed up. He had left behind a footprint below her window, though. And there had been obvious signs of tampering around the window.

“Helping this little lady. Someone wanted to hurt her enough to try and run her down.” Bryan stood up and shook the other man’s hand.

“Ms. Reynolds. Interesting meeting you again,” he said, squatting next to her. “Are you hurt?”

“Just my ankle, really. I’m fine. I think the whole incident was just some drunk driver.”

“Let me be the judge of that. Tell me what happened.”

Amber repeated the entire thing to him. Then he got Bryan’s viewpoint, along with several other people’s reports as well. By then, Tanner and Bryan had helped her up to sit on the curb. She found to her dismay that she couldn’t put any weight on her ankle.

“It’s badly sprained,” Tanner said. “Plus you’ve got scraped knees, hands, and a bruise on your left elbow that worries me.”

“What do I do about my ankle?” she asked.

“You go to the hospital and have it x-rayed to be sure there isn’t something broken in there. I can only make suppositions at this point. You need an X-ray on it and your elbow.”

“Really, is that necessary?” Amber asked. She didn’t want to go to the hospital. She hated them.

“Yes, it really is,” Tanner said with a wry smile.

“Ma’am, do I need to call an ambulance for you?” Officer McKenny asked.

“No, thanks. I can drive myself.”

“I don’t think so,” Bryan said. “That’s your right ankle. You aren’t going to be able to put any pressure on it.”

Tanner spoke up. “We’ll take you. Our truck is right around the corner.”

“Oh, I appreciate it, but it’s okay. I’ll manage.” Amber didn’t want to put anyone out.

“Nonsense. You can’t drive, and you don’t want to go by ambulance. We’ll take you.” He turned to Bryan. “Go get the truck.”

“Got you.” Bryan jogged off.

“I hate causing all this trouble,” she fussed, wringing her hands.

“You didn’t cause anything. The idiot who nearly hit you did it.”

Amber resigned herself to going to the hospital with the two men.




Amber started to reach down and grab his head to hold him still in one place, but Tanner brushed her hands aside and latched onto one of her tits. He pinched and toyed with the other nipple while he sucked and nipped at the one in his mouth. She held his head to her breast and whimpered.

Together, they were driving her insane with pleasure. Her orgasm grew deep in her belly. Her clit ached for stimulation. Occasionally Bryan would run his tongue around it, but he wouldn’t touch it and give it the relief it needed. Tanner twisted her nipple at the same time he sucked the other one flat against the roof of his mouth, and a tiny sparks flew through her system to lodge in her clit.

“Please, I need to come. One of you, make me come.” She was demanding now. She couldn’t take much more.

Bryan pushed two fingers into her cunt and curled them until he located her sweet spot. He brushed over it several times before latching onto her clit and sucking it. She bucked beneath them as she came, screaming in ecstasy. They each petted her until she stopped coming, then rubbed her arms to soothe her shivers.

Bryan lay down on his back with his cock already sheathed in a condom. She realized he wanted her on top. Amber hesitated for a second then climbed over him. She’d begged them to fuck her. It was what she’d asked for. She rose up, and Bryan held his cock steady for her to sink down on. She moaned as she only made it halfway. He was so thick. She moved up him then slid down his shaft again. This time she made it to his groin.

“Fuck, aw, fuck, baby. You’re so freaking tight.” Bryan’s voice sounded even more strained than before. It was almost as if he were in pain.

“Ride him, Amber. I want to see that pretty pussy swallow his dick.” Tanner stood behind her now. She couldn’t see him unless she looked over her shoulder.

She pulled up then dropped down slow then fast, over and over. Soon, Bryan was shoving his cock up to meet her. His hands held her hips as he pistoned into her.

“Bryan, hold her, man.” Tanner slowly pushed her down against Bryan’s chest.

Bryan wrapped his arms around her. He kissed her forehead as she rested her cheek against his chest.

Suddenly she felt something cold and wet at her asshole. She yelped and started to sit up. Bryan held her steady.

“Easy, Amber. He won’t hurt you. He’s going to prepare you.”

“I–I’ve never had anyone there before,” she said in a shaky voice.

“I know, baby. That’s why he’s going to loosen you up. We don’t want to hurt you. Just push out when he uses his fingers on you. Okay, baby?”

She squeaked out an okay and nodded her head against his chest. She wasn’t at all sure about this. She wanted to, wanted them both inside her, but she was scared at the same time.

Tanner’s finger pressed the cool gel inside her ass. He dropped a little more there and pushed it as well. This time, his finger went with it. She didn’t even have to push out for it. She let out a relieved breath. Maybe this wouldn’t be so hard after all.

He pushed his finger in and out of her several times, then added more of the lube, and added another finger. This time it pinched, and she pushed out until he made it inside with them. He pumped them in and out of her back hole over and over until they moved freely. Then he added yet more lube, and another finger joined the first two. This time it burned, and she suppressed a cry. She remembered what Bryan had said, and pushed out while trying to breathe through the burn. When the third finger made it inside, he grew still, waiting on her to get used to it, she guessed.

Amber began to twitch. She needed them to move. It was too much. They needed to move inside of her. She tried to push back and pull off his fingers, but he followed her. Finally, he began pumping them in and out of her ass in a smooth rhythm that just wasn’t fast enough for her. She whimpered and tried to speed him up, but he kept the same pace.

“More, Tanner. Faster. I need it faster.” She finally told him what she needed when it didn’t look like he was going to give it to her.

Instead, he pulled his fingers out and added more lube. Then he fitted the head of his cock against her back opening and pushed. Fire burned as he pushed his way inside of her. She pushed out against the burn. Finally, he popped through the ring of resistance and tunneled deep into her ass. He stilled and they all panted, trying to catch their breath. Amber looked up at Bryan’s face. He was covered with sweat. His cock jumped inside of her occasionally as if chomping at the bit to be let go.

Finally, she couldn’t stand it anymore and pulled back from them and shoved down, then shoved back. She heard Tanner curse then grab her hips while Bryan held her legs.

“Be still, honey. Let us do the work. We don’t want to hurt you.” Tanner squeezed her hips.

“Then move, damn you!” She couldn’t believe that was her voice demanding they fuck her.

Read more