“We can’t keep second-guessing every resident. Besides, as long as she pays her bills and follows the board’s rules, she shouldn’t be a problem,” Josh said.
“Time will tell. Paige Emmett left me feeling ambivalent after our interview,” Chris reminded him.
“I know,” Josh said, having heard the same questioning tone for weeks now. “But just because she wasn’t a chatty cat doesn’t mean she won’t fit in. Besides, she bought her unit. A sale is a sale. I’d rather see the units occupied instead of standing empty. The community doesn’t make any money on empty units.”
“Yeah, I guess,” Chris acknowledged. “I’m not used to people being so brusque with the board. Usually new applicants go out of their way to give us as much information as possible. Sometimes too much.”
“Most do, especially when their nervous about admission. You told me she was single, but you noticed she had a large untanned line on her left ring finger. That said to me she had something she wasn’t sharing.” Josh gave him a noncommittal shoulder shrug.
“You think she was married?” Chris asked. “She specifically said single, not divorced.”
Josh walked into his garage and pulled two bottles of water from the refrigerator he kept there for cold drinks and strolled back. Handing one to Chris, he leaned against the side of the SUV. “None of our business, Chris. Her background check came out clean and with no alias.”
“I guess,” Chris said, taking a long pull from his water.
“You’re just surprised because she didn’t flirt with you during the interview.”
“Flirt? She was deadpan and cranky. I hope she wasn’t a mistake.” Chris shook his head. “I feel like we’ve just invited Nurse Ratched into our cul-de-sac.”
“Hey, just because she didn’t accept your offer to sleep with you doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong. Maybe she’s coming off a bad relationship.” Josh looked at his water bottle but didn’t drink.
“Maybe she’s a lesbian.” Chris laughed at the grimace Josh’s face turned into.
“Let her go, Chris. Just because she’s close by doesn’t automatically make her affair material. Besides, how many times have we discussed not getting involved with anyone from the complex? Having exes too close is claustrophobic, at best.” The men tapped water bottles in a mock toast.
“Yeah, I guess you’re right.” They continued to lean on the side of the vehicle while finishing their water. “Have you noticed they haven’t carried in any furniture? Only boxes.”
“Maybe they took the big stuff in before we got home. Or maybe she ordered new furniture and is waiting for it to be delivered. We know she had the place painted and new hardwood and tile laid before moving in.”
“Could be,” Chris said. “She just gives me the creeps. It was the look of disdain on her face during the interview.”
“The rest of the board approved her without issues. None of them mentioned the vibe you got. They said she was prepared and professional. At least, she’s got a job.”
“At least she’s not another lawyer living on my block.” He turned and gave Josh his cynical smile. “I know things didn’t turn out too bad with you living here, but you’re human even if you are a lawyer.”
Chris let out a string of curses and pulled out of her body, ripping off the condom and spraying his load against her pussy. Josh managed to take several long, slow pumps deep inside her before he felt his cum churning and knew he couldn’t hold off any longer. He gently pushed her forward to lean against Chris and pulled from her, tearing off his condom and spraying his load on her ass cheeks and anus. He watched her hole throb and dropped a hand down. Using his come, he pushed three fingers back in her hole.
“Chris, finger her pussy,” Josh said.
Chris didn’t react but Paige did. “Chris, finger me, quick.” This time he moved, pushing three fingers in her already stretched pussy. They continued to use their fingers to fuck her holes a bit longer. Her body sucked at their fingers, pulling them deeper. Chris managed to get her nipple between his teeth and sucked. Her body betrayed her and clamped down on their fingers. She let out a sigh and would have melted to the ground if they didn’t have her sandwiched between them. Chris let his fingers slide from her pussy and Josh from her butt. He paused to palm her buttocks, pinching lightly. Paige groaned and pushed back against him.
“Oh no, lady. Not again, not without something to drink,” he teased. Josh made sure she was steady against Chris and stepped back. He reached around her and carefully pulled the bra cups over her engorged nipples, then he went and found her shirt, dropping it over her shoulders.
“Thank you,” she whispered. Chris finally released her leg and held her at the waist until she was steady.
“Coffee, water, or wine?” Chris asked.
“No wine,” she said. “Water, then coffee.”
“Same for me,” Josh told Chris. He reached for Paige’s hand and drew her with him to the table. He noticed she sat gingerly but the smile on her lips couldn’t be denied. He accepted the water bottles Chris handed around before taking his seat.
“Fresh coffee is brewing,” he said, guzzling the water from his bottle.
“Thank you, guys. I know I’m supposed to be demure during sex, but this was different with you two. I didn’t feel like I had to hide my feelings or needs.”
“Never with us,” Josh said. “That’s the difference with us, you can be yourself and that will allow us to be ourselves. Whatever we do together never leaves the three of us. It’s that trust that allows us this kind of freedom.”
Chris left but came back quickly with mugs and the coffee pot on a tray. After serving each of them, he settled into his seat. “So what would you like to try next time?”
“Are we done for the night?” she asked and waited only a second before laughing.
“Paige, what else would you like to try next time?” Josh knew he was exhausted and even though she was putting up a good front, he could tell she was tired too. He figured after the low wore off, her holes would be sore from being stretched, apparently like never before.
“Next time, I think I’d like to watch you two together. I want to see how you suck and fuck each other.”
“Maybe. The mood would have to be right,” Josh told her.
“What are you doing to do while we pleasure each other?” Chris asked.