A Case of Mistaken Identity (MMMM)

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 49,160
6 Ratings (4.5)

[Siren Menage Amour Manlove: Multiple Partners, Science Fiction, Futuristic, Alternative, MMMM, HEA]

Frederick Hunter, Phoenix Chapman, and Sawyer Dunlap need a replacement housekeeper and chef. They decide to get a male android, which looks and feels almost as real as a human being.

Carl Hensley can get pregnant. The explosion at the nuclear power plant three decades ago altered the chemical compositions in the air, soil, and water, irreversibly changing the human genetics. Carl's conservative and religious parents don't like it. When they try to sell him off to a shady dealer, he escapes, eventually coming upon Frederick, Phoenix, and Sawyer's house. The three men think Carl is the android they've been waiting for. When the misunderstanding is cleared up, Carl stays with them. Feelings soon develop among them. Then abductions of men like Carl occur in the town they live in, and Carl ends up as one of the victims.

Can Frederick, Sawyer, and Phoenix rescue Carl before anything bad happens to him?

A Case of Mistaken Identity (MMMM)
6 Ratings (4.5)

A Case of Mistaken Identity (MMMM)

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 49,160
6 Ratings (4.5)
In Bookshelf
In Cart
In Wish List
Available formats
Cover Art by Harris Channing
Great story.


“Now, let’s get down to business,” Frederick said. “I believe Nancy should have installed all the necessary software into your system. That means you’re able to clean the house, do our laundry, and prepare our meals for us. Will you be able to cook for us? Starting from this evening. We’ve already stocked up the pantry and fridge with many food items since we knew you’d be arriving soon.”

Carl wondered if he had somehow traveled into another dimension and landed in a weird world or something, but he continued to play along. He had no idea what was going on, but he didn’t want to offend these three men. He couldn’t fight them all, and if they were as wacky as they appeared to be, they might have superhuman strength or something.

“I can do that. That won’t be a problem at all. I need to tell you something, though.”

“What’s that?” Phoenix inquired while still jabbing at Carl’s cheek. “Holy shit! You feel so real.”

“Uh, right. See, I got here by car, but something had gone wrong with it. It's now stranded out there.”

“Damn it!” Frederick exclaimed. “Are you implying the driver is still out there in the car?”

“What? You don’t understand. I’m the one who dri—”

“Fred, we better use the tow truck from the garage and rescue the delivery guy,” Sawyer interrupted Carl and addressed Frederick instead. “It isn’t safe for the car to remain outside. This thunderstorm may last for quite a while.”

Before Carl could explain himself further, Frederick and Sawyer ran out from the front door. On the other hand, Phoenix was now gawking at Carl as if he was an alien or something.

“M-may I dry myself somewhere, please?”

Phoenix seemed to be startled upon hearing that. He studied Carl from head to toe. Then he pulled Carl into a huge bedroom and provided him with a towel and some dry clothes before pointing at the bathroom.

“Sawyer’s clothes will probably fit you. You may change in there.”

Carl heaved out a sigh of relief when he was alone inside the bathroom. He removed his wet clothes and rubbed himself dry with the towel before putting on the clothes that Phoenix had loaned him. The shirt and sweatpants were quite loose on him, but at least he was no longer dripping wet. He walked out from the bathroom and followed Phoenix back to the living room. Neither of them exchanged a single word because Carl didn’t quite know what to say while Phoenix was back to staring at him. Sawyer and Frederick returned into the house a few minutes later.

“We’ve towed the car all the way into the garage, but we can’t find the delivery guy,” Sawyer said while shaking his arms to get rid of some of the water droplets on his face. “Damn thunderstorm. Not even the umbrella and my raincoat can keep me dry. Oh, by the way, I don’t get why the company has to deliver you in such an old, beat-up car. It’s also crammed full of bags and boxes.”

Carl could feel himself blushing. He knew the state of his car was anything but pristine. He was about to inquire about where his car had been stored for the moment when he heard someone’s phone ringing loudly. It was Frederick’s. Carl watched as Frederick answered the call and listened attentively for a brief moment. Then he noticed Frederick’s eyes widening as the man gazed straight into his eyes. He gulped in trepidation when Frederick hung up and approached him, seemingly enraged.

“Who the fuck are you?”


“Fred,” Phoenix shouted at Frederick. “Babe, what’s going on? This is Carl. He’s our new android. Have you lost your damn marbles or something?”

“No, he’s not! That was Nancy on the phone earlier. There had been a fire at the store at around half past nine o’clock in the morning. Most of the androids had been burned and destroyed, including the one we paid for. Nancy hadn’t been able to get in touch with us or any of the other customers because she had to deal with the police, the fire department, and the insurance company. She hadn’t been able to access any of the customers’ data until several minutes ago. The store will reimburse us the money within the next three days because the company that owns it doesn’t know when or if it will be able to produce any new androids within the next six months or more.”

After listening to the long-winded explanation, Carl realized there must have been a misunderstanding between them. He burst out laughing while Frederick, Sawyer, and Phoenix glanced at him as if he was crazy. He shook his head at all three men before pointing in the direction of the kitchen.

“I’ve been trying to explain myself right from the beginning. None of you gave me the opportunity to talk. Shall we go into the kitchen? I’ll make us some tea, if you have any. Tea will help to calm us down.”


“I promise I’m not a runaway from a mental hospital or an escaped convict,” Carl interrupted Sawyer in a hurry.



Carl allowed Frederick to pump that huge, hard cock in and out of his mouth and throat for several moments before giving Phoenix the same treatment. Phoenix was even more appreciative of his newly discovered ability, and his husband savored it for quite a while. Then he whimpered in disappointment when he felt Sawyer abandoning his ass. He craved for Sawyer’s tongue inside his ass. His hole felt empty, and he itched to get something larger, harder, and hotter inside it. Fortunately, his husbands seemed to know just what he needed. Frederick lifted him gently away from Phoenix’s cock. He straddled Frederick’s hips gratefully before he shoved himself back against his husband’s cock and rammed it deep into his hole all at once.

“Fuck, baby! Ride my fucking cock!”

Carl obeyed Frederick’s instruction enthusiastically, grasping onto his husband’s sweaty, hairy, and muscular chest while fucking himself on that incredible cock over and over again. He was enjoying himself so much, he was taken aback when someone grasped onto his hips from behind to halt his movement. He turned himself around and gasped in delight when he felt the tip of Phoenix’s cock kissing the rim of his hole. He almost lost his breath when Phoenix thrust forward. He thought he was about to faint from the pain and pleasure that coursed through his entire being when the head of Phoenix’s cock slipped into him. He simultaneously gritted his teeth and relaxed himself as Phoenix slid his cock deeper into him. He slumped down onto Frederick’s chest. Their perspiration somehow glued the two of them together. Carl felt as if he was about to lose his mind when he eventually got all of Phoenix’s cock along with Frederick’s equally hard cock right underneath it all the way inside his ass.

“How does it feel, baby?” Phoenix whispered from somewhere above him. “Are you getting enough cocks inside your hungry hole?”

Carl panted as he was being impaled by two enormous cocks inside his ass. “I…I want—”

“What’s that, baby?” Sawyer, who was now kneeling in front of Frederick, Carl, and Phoenix, inquired in a raspy voice. “Not enough? It’s okay. I know just what you need. Open that pretty mouth for me.”

Carl obliged immediately, and he rumbled deep in his throat when Sawyer instantly forced his cock into his mouth and all the way down his throat. He had his husbands’ cocks inside him, and he was feeling even hornier than before. For the next several minutes, his husbands rammed their cocks into him without mercy, but he wasn’t complaining. He was having the time of his life. However, he was astonished when Sawyer abruptly pushed his head back and moved away from him. He had no idea what Sawyer was going to do next, but he couldn’t really think about it. He had two other cocks pounding into his ass, providing him with so much pleasure. However, he stiffened in shock for a few seconds when Phoenix pressed his whole body downward and rose up higher behind him right before he felt the tip of a third cock trying to worm its way into his ass.

“I-I can’t.”

Frederick nipped and licked at Carl’s neck while gently caressing his arms. “Yes, you can. It’s what you’ve been yearning for, isn’t it?”

“That’s the reason you had such a massive butt plug inside your ass for the entire duration of our wedding reception. Am I right? I should know because Fred, Sawyer, and I had already fucked you several minutes prior to the reception. That can only mean that you must have inserted the butt plug into your ass after showering and right before the reception. You’re turning into a nasty slut, aren’t you? Our filthy, desperate slut.”

Carl could feel the flush of embarrassment threatening to overwhelm him, but he couldn’t deny what Frederick and Phoenix had just told him. He wouldn’t want to anyway. His husbands were accurate in their assessment. The truth was he had been planning and hoping to get all three of their cocks inside his ass. He craved to know how it felt to be stuffed with all three of their cocks. He didn’t even care if he ended up losing his consciousness from the exertion and the effort. He was determined to try. As Sawyer’s cock slid deeper into his already jam-packed hole, he began to see stars. It was painful, but it felt really wonderful at the same time. His ass felt really full, but the sensation was nothing compared to the moment his husbands began to thrust into him.

He couldn’t describe every single sensation. His ass hurt like a motherfucking atomic bomb was being shoved into it, but having three cocks inside his ass was like nothing he had ever experienced before. He hung on for his dear life as his husbands clobbered into his ass. 

Read more