Alyssa's Choice (MFM)

Journey of a Thousand Miles 3

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 51,315
26 Ratings (4.3)

[Siren Ménage Everlasting: Erotic Ménage a Trois Romance, M/F/M, voyeurism, HEA]

Alyssa Fredricks didn’t come from a good family, so she adopted her friends Bella and Jessica to be her family. When Bella asks her to go on a road trip, she jumps at the chance to get away from San Diego and a past she wants to forget.

Grant Hollis and Justin Truman are co-owners of Spread Eagle, a pub in Coltmann County. The first night Alyssa’s in town she gets their attention with her curvy body and her sultry voice. They have been looking for the perfect woman to share and they think Alyssa could be the one they’ve been waiting for.

A surprise twist throws Alyssa off and sends her running back to California. When she comes back with her tail between her legs, will Grant and Justin be able to forgive her? Can a woman with so many insecurities forget the past and embrace the future?

A Siren Erotic Romance


Alicia White is a Siren-exclusive author.

Alyssa's Choice (MFM)
26 Ratings (4.3)

Alyssa's Choice (MFM)

Journey of a Thousand Miles 3

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 51,315
26 Ratings (4.3)
In Bookshelf
In Cart
In Wish List
Available formats
Cover Art by Les Byerley
I really liked this story!!
it was a good read and it was nice to have a little controversy over what she needed to do about her surprise



Alyssa walked into the pub and noticed that the place was full of gorgeous men. How could so many good-looking men be in one place? The odds had to be slim. She walked with Bella to the bar and took a seat. Spread Eagle, the name played around in her mind for a while and conjured up many scenarios. Of course, she was the main star in all of them. When the bartender walked up, he became the main acting role. His dirty blond hair hit his collar, his eyes were blue and not just an average run-of-the-mill blue. They were deep like the ocean on a clear day. He wore a tight, white T-shirt that sculpted his muscular arms and stomach. She licked her lips, wishing she could be the lucky girl to tear that shirt off his body.

“Good evening, ladies, what can I get you?” His voice did things to her she never expected. It was deep, the kind of voice a woman wanted to hear when she was in bed.

She tried to play it off, acting casual. She didn’t want him to notice she was squirming in her seat.

“Can we get two shots of tequila and a couple of beers? Whatever you have on tap’s fine.” The bartender gave a nod and started grabbing some glasses.

“So, are you ladies visiting or are you moving here?” He tried to make casual conversation, although he did seem a bit nervous.

“We’re just passing through. Our car broke down, so I guess we’re here until it gets fixed,” Alyssa told him.

“I’m sorry to hear that. I’m Justin Truman, and my partner over there”—he nodded his head toward the other side of the bar—“is Grant Hollis.”

“Nice to meet you.” Alyssa snuck a peek over her shoulder. She swallowed the lump that suddenly appeared in her throat. Across the room stood a huge man, his thick arms crossed over his chest. He was incredibly gorgeous, and she stared at him, wondering what those arms would feel like wrapped around her. He kept scanning the room, watching everyone. He appeared to be relaxed, but she could tell he was alert. She turned and gave her attention back to Justin, the gorgeous bartender. “I’m Alyssa Fredricks, and this is my friend Bella Williams.” She quickly made the introductions.

Alyssa’s gaze traveled from Justin over to Grant. She wasn’t really paying attention to what Bella was saying to her. She couldn’t seem to focus. What did “partner” mean? Could they both be looking to share? She couldn’t imagine Grant being the type. He looked so in control. The air around him was one of superiority. She turned back to her drink, catching Justin’s eye. He gave her a wink and poured her another shot. The best thing she could do was get a little tipsy then walk back to her motel room, masturbate, and fall into a deep sleep.

Alyssa watched Bella go to the stage. She usually didn’t sing. It was funny to think that she was feeling so courageous. The Colton brothers sat in a far booth, all eyes trained on her, as she went on the stage. It was so utterly romantic her heart felt heavy. She downed the rest of her drink and waved over the new bartender who took Justin’s place. The new guy definitely wasn’t as hot, but she didn’t care. Her new goal was to just get trashed and forget that she was single.

Why couldn’t men look at her that way? She got her fair share of attention, but no man had ever looked at her like that. It was romantic, the way their eyes filled with such love. She waved for another shot. The Patrón was going down smooth tonight. How many shots was that? Did it really matter? Nope, she decided to keep it up. The bartender poured her another as Bella walked back to the bar.

“So, Alyssa, it’s your turn. What are you gonna sing?” Bella asked.

“It’s a surprise, just for you. I think I’m up next,” Alyssa told her. She walked on stage and Bella smiled at her. The song started and Alyssa started to sing Train’s “Marry Me.” Her eyes traveled over the crowd, and she saw Grant. He walked closer to the small stage, his eyes trained on her, and she smiled a little, feeling a tingly sensation travel from her stomach to the rest of her body. The intense look in his eyes captured her and held her in place.

People walked onto the dance floor, and she wanted to be one of those girls, having a beautiful man holding her in his arms. She saw Bella and Clint dancing together. They were so cute, the song bringing them closer.

The song ended, and Alyssa walked off the stage, handing off the microphone to the next singer. It was time for another drink. She was almost to her goal. Next was the motel room. Luckily, Bella wasn’t drinking that much. She needed a helping hand. Justin still wasn’t behind the bar, so she ordered another drink and turned to watch Bella being surrounded by her three men. They looked happy. How depressing.

She turned around and faced the bar. Justin stood in front of her with a glass of water in one hand and a cup of coffee in the other. She didn’t want either one of them. She wanted another drink. “Where the fuck is my drink?” Her words came out slurred.

Justin quickly answered, “Ladies shouldn’t curse. It doesn’t sound attractive.”

Alyssa yelled back, “Oh, yeah, well fuck you!” She hated men who thought they could boss her around. All she wanted was another drink. She wasn’t driving. This was ridiculous. “Listen, Justin, I’m not driving. I can handle another drink. Bella is gonna walk me back to the motel. Okay.”

“No. You’re cut off. And if you keep up with this attitude, you’re gonna be sorry.” He smirked at her. The asshole actually smirked. Who the hell did he think he was?

“I’ve had enough. Fine. Fuck it! I’m leaving.” She stood up and would have stumbled if Grant hadn’t grabbed her.

“Again with the language, Alyssa. Bad girl. If you’re not going to act like a lady, then you’ll be punished.”




“I want you to lie on your back and open your legs wide. Grant gets the first taste.” Justin climbed onto the bed and kissed her lips, moving farther down, laying nibbles and love bites across her neck and chest. When he reached her breasts, he sucked her nipples tightly into his mouth. She concentrated on the sensations, having him alternate between hard bites and soft licks.

She felt warm air being blown onto her pussy, and she arched her hips, knowing that Grant was going to taste her. Strong hands gripped her thighs and pushed them farther apart, making more room for him. She held her breath, wondering what he would do next. She didn’t have to wait long. Grant pulled apart the lips of her pussy, his fingers moving around, avoiding her clit. She couldn’t see him, but she felt like she was under a microscope, getting an inspection, and she hoped that she would pass his test. He moved closer to her and she felt his face against her pussy, and she knew he was smelling her. When he groaned loudly, she felt her body relax into the bed.

“Does she taste good, Grant?” Justin asked, lifting his face from her chest. Grant nodded but didn’t remove his mouth from her. He started licking, long tongue swipes up and down her crease. She moved her hips, shoving her pussy farther against his face, but he wouldn’t let her take over. Grant moved his hands, shoving them under her ass, holding onto her tight.

She felt Justin move and she opened her eyes. He got to his knees next to her face and started stroking his cock. She didn’t need to be asked. She reached out and grabbed his cock and felt it jolt in her hand. He gasped and moved closer to her, grabbing a pillow and helping her move her head to get her mouth lined up with his hard shaft. Clear fluid gathered on the tip, and she used her thumb to spread it over the head before she stuck her tongue out and licked the head of his cock. His flavor exploded on her tongue, and she was surprised at how sweet he tasted.

She sucked his cock into her mouth on a loud slurp, wanting to shove it all the way down her throat. She swirled her tongue around his shaft, feeling his soft satin skin against his powerful, hard length. She moved her mouth faster, wanting to please him, wanting to show him that she loved the feel of his cock in her mouth. She held her tongue rigid, holding his shaft, and slid the head of his cock back and forth across her tongue quickly. She reached one hand back and gently held his balls, kneading them, pulling on them.

“Oh, God, baby, your mouth. Shit. Fantastic!” He grabbed her head, digging his fingers into her scalp, and started fucking her mouth harder. Taking away her control, he used fast movements, and she relaxed her mouth completely. She watched him half lidded, wanting to see his face and watch his reaction when he climaxed. His eyes closed tight, his jaw ridged, and his muscles were flexing.

“I’m so close. Oh, Alyssa. You are perfect!” He threw his head back and yelled out her name and she felt his cock jerk. Warm cum filled her mouth. She swallowed quickly, trying to taste every drop of him. He pulled back, panting, and she stared at him. He looked wild and untamed.

Grant renewed his efforts on her pussy, and she looked down at him, concentrating on the pleasure he was giving her. He had started out slow, tasting every part of her. He devoured her now, shoving his tongue in and out of her pussy hard and fast. She needed more, though, so much more, and she wasn’t sure how long she would have to wait for what she really wanted. She loved his mouth, but she wanted a cock. It had been so long since she had been taken. Fucked. It had been too long without a toy being involved.

Justin must’ve seen the distress on her face. He moved closer, grabbing her nipples and pinching them in between his thumb and forefinger. He pulled hard, making her arch her back as the pain and pleasure rained through her system. He moved a hand down until he reached her clit and massaged in hard little circles, bringing her closer to the edge, letting her feel her climax bloom.

Grant moved his fingers, pushing them into her slowly. She could feel her body tighten on them, and he moved, pumping in and out of her. She was on sensation overload. She was pushed to the edge, closer to climax.

He pumped his fingers faster, and Justin flicked her clit hard, throwing her over the edge. She screamed their names as her orgasm washed over her, through her, shaking her uncontrollably. She felt two sets of hands on her, rubbing her body up and down, making her feel relaxed and calming her breathing. She finally opened her eyes and looked between them. They were both smiling and staring at her as if she meant the world to them.

“You are so beautiful when you come. Hearing my name on your lips, amazing.” Grant moved in and kissed her deeply. She opened her mouth and tasted herself on his tongue. She moaned deeply and pulled him closer, wrapping her legs around his hips. He was still dressed, and she could feel his hard length poking her in the stomach. She wanted to take care of him, as he had just pleasured her. Their kiss deepened, and she groaned.

Grant pulled away from her, and she reluctantly let him go. He stepped back and started stripping off his clothes and she sat up, wanting a better view. She felt warm breath against her neck and leaned into Justin. “Grant is going to lie on the bed, and I want to watch you sit on top of his cock.” She watched Grant expose his hard shaft, and she moaned. “I want you to take his cock like a good girl, nice and slow, while I play with your little asshole.”

Read more