Plenty to Believe (MFM)

Plenty, FL 5

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 51,945
16 Ratings (4.2)

[Siren Ménage Everlasting: Erotic Ménage a Trois Romance, M/F/M, consensual BDSM, bondage, spanking, sex toys, HEA]

Leah Holt’s the town bookworm, used to fading into the background. Former rock star Justin Reynolds and his manager, Linc Davis, could never be interested in a girl like her, but she can’t help fantasizing. They’re sexier than any hero in her romance novels.

Justin’s head over heels for Leah’s shy, sexy ways. She’s not impressed with their former rock star glory. He wants to build a future and a family with her. Linc’s fallen for Leah, too. She’s amazing, the smartest woman he’s ever met. And that’s the problem.

Leah’s the one woman Linc can never be with. He pushes her away, determined she’ll never know his shameful secret. Justin is equally determined to push all three of them together, frustrated with his best friend’s stubborn behavior.

When Linc’s actions break Leah’s heart, he has to tell her the truth, no matter the cost to himself. Is it too late to make her believe in their love?

A Siren Erotic Romance


Lara Valentine is a Siren-exclusive author.

Plenty to Believe (MFM)
16 Ratings (4.2)

Plenty to Believe (MFM)

Plenty, FL 5

Siren-BookStrand, Inc.

Heat Rating: Sextreme
Word Count: 51,945
16 Ratings (4.2)
In Bookshelf
In Cart
In Wish List
Available formats
Cover Art by Les Byerley
Omg this was fantastic! !!! Nothing better then some plenty :-) loved loved loved it!!!! Sweet loving and sexy as sin, can not wait for more
donna b buccella
I would have to say that Plenty to Believe was my favorite story in the Plenty, Florida series so far. It is the fifth book and I was completely taken in by the first chapter. Leah, the town's bookworm falls for two hot, sexy men Justin and Linc. Although Linc pushes her away to begin with they all end up getting through happily ever after. I love how Lara Valentine creates characters that you really care about from the beginning and you root for them through the whole book. I am looking forward to reading more from this talented author.
Professional Reviews

5 HEARTS: "Retired rock star Justin Reynolds and his manager and best friend Linc Davis have retired to Plenty, Florida where they are looking to settle down, start and family and build some roots. They have found the perfect woman in the quiet and shy Leah Holt who is beautiful, loving, and who challenges the men on so many different levels that their lives will never be dull. Now all they have to do is convince Leah that they are the men to satisfy her every desire and maybe a few she hasn’t ever thought of; looks like the night in Plenty just got a little hotter. Leah knows that men like Justin and Linc would never be interested in her but that doesn’t stop her from fantasizing about what it would be like to be in the middle between these two smoking hot dominate men. Author Lara Valentine latest story in the Plenty, Florida series is a delectably lively, fast-paced tale sprinkled with humor, heat and a little bit of suspense to keep the reader craving page after page. Every story I have read by this wonderful author her style of writing always flows smoothly and her way with words keeps the reader captivated providing the perfect escape to entertain and delight her audience. There is something irresistible about two sexy bad boys and Justin and Linc fit the mark perfectly. They are bold characters who demand the attention of the reader with their strong, tender and dominate personalities as well as their honest approach to life and love. They aren’t afraid, in fact they demand that Leah stand up to them and not let them get away with anything; they make sure she understands she has the power. The connection between Leah and her men is filled with a few clever ups and downs that are not only believable but that help strengthen the bond between the characters. Readers will also enjoy watching Leah break out of her quiet shell, turning into a sensual woman filled with sass, wit and possessing a strength from within that she has kept hidden. The smoking hot sex scenes are filled with BDSM elements, playful fun, passion and emotions. The other leading ladies from past stories in this series work their magic as supporting characters helping Leah to relish her new nature and zest for life, family and friends. The ending is pure romance and will have the reader sigh as Linc and Justin literally sweep their lady love off of her feet. Ms. Valentine once again heats up the pages in this sassy and sexy series that shouldn’t be missed." -- Shannon, The Romance Studio

Read more




Justin handed Linc his coffee. They were sitting in Josh’s Java after their shopping trip to Leah’s bookstore. Linc wasn’t in the fucking mood to talk and it was clear Justin was frustrated as hell with his best friend.

“Why are you acting this way? I know you’re attracted to her. Not your type my ass. I see the way you look at her when she’s not watching.”

Linc scowled over his coffee. “You’re seeing things, buddy. Leah’s not my type. You know I like them blonde, busty, and uncomplicated. Leah’s complicated. She’s got ‘complicated’ written all over her.”

“If that’s your way of saying she’s smarter than hell, you’re right. I like a woman who knows how to spell her own name and doesn’t dot the ‘i’ with a little heart or flower.”

Linc smirked. “Are you saying the ladies I date are dumb? I’m not attracted to their scintillating conversation. I have you for that.”

“I don’t think you’re attracted to them at all. I think Leah is your type. She’s my type and we’re attracted to the same women.”

Linc stretched out his long legs. “She doesn’t look like the women we’ve dated in the past.”

That, at least, was the truth. Leah was infinitely more beautiful than any woman he’d had in his life before. She was petite, her body slight. Linc guessed she barely weighed a hundred pounds soaking wet. Her hips were rounded, but trim, her bottom a sweet, sexy curve. Her breasts were small and firm, but the perfect size for his hand. Her skin was creamy, damn near perfect. Her eyes were a soft, warm brown that made a man’s heart pound and his stomach twist into knots. Her lips were full and he’d fought the urge to kiss her dozens of times. He could get lost gazing at her beautiful face, his hand stroking her shiny, gorgeous hair. It was the most unusual color and looked like silk. He wanted to rub the strands between his fingers and bury his face in her neck, breathing in her sweet scent.

He wasn’t going to do any of those things.

Justin sipped his coffee. “Exactly. I’m done with casual sex and women who are only in it to be with someone famous. I want a real relationship, with a real woman. I want someone I can love and build a family with. I thought that’s what you wanted, too. It’s what we talked about when we moved here.”

It was what they talked about. Linc wanted the love of a good woman as much, maybe even more, than Justin did. The woman simply couldn’t be Leah, although, he couldn’t imagine himself with anyone else. His attraction to her was strong. He liked and respected her, too. She was the kind of woman a man was proud of, and would want her to be proud of him in return.

“When we find the right woman, I want those things. All of them. The right woman isn’t Leah. I’m sorry.” Linc stared out the front window of the coffee shop watching the residents of Plenty pass by. He loved this damn town. He’d chosen well when he’d told Justin they should move here.

“Listen, you really seem to have feelings for Leah. If you want to go your own way, I understand.”

Justin’s lips tightened. He was pissing off his best friend. If only Linc could tell him he wasn’t all that happy about it either. When Linc was around Leah, his chest was tight and his heart sped up. She was gorgeous, her innocent beauty tempting him to forget why they could never be together.

“I don’t want to go my own damn way. I want to share Leah with you.” Justin stood and headed back to the counter. “We’re having dinner with Leah tomorrow night. You’re going to be nice and charming. We’re going to start courting her, dammit. Eventually, I’ll find out why you’re lying. In the meantime, suck it up, buttercup. Leah’s the one. You know it. I know it. And starting tomorrow night, we’re going to let Leah know it.”

Linc stroked his goatee as Justin strode up to the counter to talk to Josh. Having Leah in his home was a dream come true and a nightmare, all at the same time. He’d fantasized about having her there, cooking in the kitchen, watching the big-screen television while they cuddled on the couch, and of course, making love in his big bed. The more he was with her, the more he wanted to be with her. She was shy and quiet, but her quick, intelligent mind and loving heart shone through.

She’s not for me.

He would be friendly and polite tomorrow night, but he wasn’t going to court her. Justin could have her. He loved Justin like a brother. If Leah was the one for him, Linc would step aside and let him have her. He wanted them to be happy more than anything.

Linc took a big gulp of the hot liquid feeling it burn all the way down his throat. He wasn’t being a selfless hero giving Leah up to Justin.

Linc was protecting himself.




She moved to her hands and knees, Justin pushing her thighs wide apart, Linc near her head. His hard cock was mere inches from her face and she gave the head a lick, tasting his sweet and salty pre-cum. He hissed and pointed to Justin.

“Give her a smack on the ass for being a naughty little girl.”

Before she could protest, Justin’s large hand landed on her bottom and she jumped at the sharp contact. She was about to turn around and tell him he had spanked her too hard when the pain turned into a heat spreading to her pussy and clit. She wriggled her ass, wanting more.

Justin chuckled. “She likes it. I thought she would. Don’t worry, honey. You’ll get all you can handle from me and Linc. We love nothing better than to spank a cute little rear end like yours all night. Eventually, we’ll fuck it, too.”

His finger trailed down into her ass crack and circled her tight rosette. “Would you like that? Do you want us to fuck your ass, honey?”

She was already climbing toward orgasm again. Linc’s fingers had reached under her and were playing with her nipples while Justin’s finger was teasing her back door.

“Yes,” she gasped. “I want you to do whatever you want. Spank it, fuck it. Whatever.”

Justin leaned over and nipped at her shoulder. “We’ll do both those things. The fucking will need to wait for another night, but it will happen.”

He leaned down and grabbed his pants and pulled out a condom. “You want a spit roast, huh? Do you want the Eiffel Tower as well?”

She’d never heard of the Eiffel Tower.

“What’s that?”

Linc fisted his cock so it was right under her nose. He had a big grin on his face and she was once more taken aback by how handsome he looked when he was smiling.

“It’s when the two guys high five over the woman at the end.”

She turned back to give Justin a dirty look. “Don’t you dare.”

Justin rolled on the condom with a smirk. “I wouldn’t do it even if you double-dog dared me.”


“Yes, honey?”

“I double-dog dare you to spank and fuck me.”

He was deep inside her in one hard thrust, taking her breath away. “Dare accepted. What about Linc?”

She looked up into Linc’s dark eyes, not cold and lifeless this time. They were hot with arousal, the golden ring around the pupil glowing. She took a deep breath.

“I double-dog dare you to pull my hair and fuck my face.”

“I thought you wanted Justin to pull your hair.”

Smart ass.

“I’m about to change my mind about both of you, sending you home with blue balls.”

They both laughed. Justin pressed a kiss to the ass cheek he’d spanked. “Give us hell, honey.”

Linc’s cock was pressing her lips for entry and she opened wide to let him all the way in. He was big and her mouth was small but she stretched her jaws wide to take as much as she could. He patted her cheek.

“Easy. Don’t try and take it all.”

His fingers wound through her thick hair, anchoring her head into place. His other hand cupped her jaw gently, but firmly, tucking a stray strand of hair behind her ear. Justin’s hand were gripping her hips, starting to take shallow thrusts. She loved the feeling of being under their control, her honey dripping from her pussy in response. She had so many things she’d read about she was going to want to try. Tonight was only the beginning. She was going to talk to them about tying her up next time.

Linc had taken control and was thrusting slowly in and out of her mouth, the ridges of his cock running over her tongue. She relaxed her jaw and tried to take him deeper, the head of his cock bumping the back of her throat. She swallowed on him, dragging a groan from his lips.

One glance up and she could see he was deep in the pleasure zone, his head thrown back, his teeth bared, the cords of his neck standing out. It was unbearably sexy to be watching him this way while she sucked on his thick cock. Every time she flicked her tongue on the underside of his dick, she could see his reaction in his expression.


She jumped when Justin’s hand came down on her ass cheek, sending a streak of heat straight to her cunt. His cock was stroking deeper into her pussy and she pressed back with each thrust, trying to take him as deeply as she could.

She was being fucked hard from both ends and her arousal rose with every stroke of their hard cocks. It was dirty, raunchy, and she wanted to experience it every day for the rest of her life. She’d never felt so much pleasure at one time. Making love to both her men made her feel complete.

Justin was spanking her hard and she kept arching her back, inviting his punishment. This was what she had fantasized about so many times. It was a million trillion times better in reality. She wanted him to spank her harder and faster. Each time his hand came down on her bottom, her whole body tingled and quaked.

Linc’s fingers tightened in her hair. “I’m ready to blow, baby.”

She tightened her lips around his cock and flitted her tongue back and forth, giving him butterfly kisses on his dick. He groaned her name and she could feel him swell inside her mouth as his cum jetted into her throat. She drank every hot drop until he had nothing left to give her. He leaned back and reached under her, playing with her nipples, twisting them and giving her a bite of pain.

“Like that, baby? Do you want me to stop?”

Read more