“We’re happy for you guys,” he said but felt his tone weaken.
“We’re glad, but this is just the beginning,” Cooper told him. “We were kind of hoping that you both felt the same attraction to Catalina. It’s why we called and told you about the job offer and to consider moving here. We’re tired of the way things were. Treasure Town is an amazing town filled with great people. You two would love it here. Maybe consider staying here with us. We’re supposed to look at some houses for sale this Sunday.”
Jeremy exhaled as he stood up. He paced half the room.
“Did you even discuss this with Catalina? I mean she met the two of you, has an attraction to the both of you, but you can’t force this kind of relationship, Coop.”
“Don’t you think we know that? We talked to her about it in the beginning. Her fear is that she doesn’t want to be a possession, an item.”
“That’s understandable. But is she even interested in a ménage relationship with four men?” Cody asked.
“She’s not dead set against it. Her friends are involved in them. We said we’d take things slow, and we have,” Cooper stated and looked at Don.
“You sleep with her yet?” Jeremy asked.
“No. It’s new. Your timing is perfect, Jeremy. She could be the woman we’ve been waiting for, the one that completes this family,” Cooper said to him.
“But Cody and I don’t know what we’re doing about work yet. It wouldn’t be fair to try and have a long-distance relationship until we can figure shit out. It is bad timing,” he said, feeling insecure about the whole thing and not even knowing if Catalina was attracted to him and Cody too.
“Let’s just see how tonight goes. She’s really sweet and a damn good kisser,” Don stated and leaned back, placing his arms behind his head as he exhaled.
“And she’ll probably cater to you all night as you pretend to be some invalid,” Cooper said and threw a pillow at his brother’s head.
“Hey. I could have lost my fucking leg.”
“But you didn’t.”
Jeremy and Cody laughed.
“I’m going to go pick up Catalina. One of you want to come with me?” Cooper asked Jeremy and Cody.”
“You think that’s a good idea?” Cody asked.
“If she’s going to get used to all of us as a package deal and get to know you then, yes, it’s a good idea,” Cooper said.
“You go, Jeremy. I’ll sit here with Don,” Cody said.
“No, you go. Don and Coop stink at cooking. I can get the potatoes ready and sauté the vegetables while Don takes a little nap,” he teased, and they chuckled.
Cody stood up and wiped his hands on his jeans. “I’ll be right back,” he said and exited the room.
Jeremy looked at Cooper.
“I don’t want to ruin this for you guys. I’m really not in the right frame of mind. I know we talked about being a family, following our parents’ tradition, but things have changed so much. I don’t even know what I want to do with my life. I’m not even sure I know if I can do anything different from being an undercover agent. I just feel out of sorts right now.”
“It’s understandable, and there’s no pressure here. All we ask is that you’re honest about what you feel and, if you’re attracted to Catalina, that you take your time and you don’t fake anything. Don and I feel she’s the one. If you and Cody can’t love her and don’t feel it like we do, then don’t lie or pretend. Just move on because we’ll always be your brothers no matter what.”
Jeremy nodded as Cody came out smiling.
“All good, Romeo?” Cooper teased.
“Well, you had a first date with her. I don’t want to come across as an escort or third wheel, okay?”
“So you want to kill her with cologne?” Cooper teased and waved his hand in front of his nose as if trying to get rid of the smell of men’s cologne.
“No, I want her to win her heart with my sexy, masculine ways. You’re just jealous because I’m bigger,” Cody told Cooper and Jeremy, and Don chuckled.
“Your head is bigger, that’s for sure. Let’s go.”
“My head is bigger than all of yours, and not the one on my shoulders. Peace out, Don, Jeremy. We’ll be back with something sweet and sexy. Start cooking dinner,” Cody teased, and Jeremy shook his head and Cooper chuckled.
“Oh God, he is going to embarrass us tonight.”
“So fucking wet and tight. Damn, baby, you are perfect and so giving,” Cody said while he thrust his fingers and then licked along her lips.
He alternated tongue and fingers, and she moaned again and lifted her hips upward. Jeremy released her lips and moved along to the side, where he cupped her breast and then began to feast on her breast, tugging on her nipple.
Cooper was back exploring her other breast and nipple, and then Cody’s mouth suckled hard on her pussy, eliciting a squeal from her throat, and she came again.
He slurped and licked, cleaning her up, and then lifted up, smiling. “Fucking delicious.”
She turned away, feeling embarrassed and turned on, and she locked gazes with Don. He sat in the chair right to the side, his pants unzipped, his cock in his hand. Their gazes locked, and he looked so carnal and needy. She wanted to go to him and ease that ache, but then Cody was moving and Cooper was taking his place. There was no preamble, just fingers thrusting into her cunt and Cooper’s lips, tongue, and teeth feasting on her pussy lips and then her anus. She nearly shot off the table when he touched her there, but Jeremy held down her shoulder and gripped her chin.
“What’s my brother doing to you, baby?”
“Oh God, this is wild. Too much.” She moaned as Cooper suckled her pussy with his mouth, and then she would feel his tongue roll between her pussy lips and over her anus. Back and forth, every stroke made her feel so needy and aroused.
“Oh God. Oh, Cooper.”
“What is he doing? Tell me,” Jeremy demanded, and she felt her pussy cream.
“Fuck, I think she likes your tone, Jeremy. She’s leaking like a fucking faucet,” Cooper said and then licked again.
Jeremy held her gaze and leaned down closer.
“Where is his tongue stroking?”
She felt her chest tighten, and she knew she loved this. She was turned on by his demanding tone, his big muscles, and his need to hear the dirty talk.
“My pussy,” she whispered, and Cooper slowly pressed a finger to her anus.
She thrust upward.
“And?” Cooper pushed.
“My ass. Oh God I never…” She moaned, and then she shook as she came.
She was panting for breath as Jeremy held her gaze.
“Ever been with more than one man?”
She shook her head fast.
“Ever have a cock in your ass?” he asked, and she shook her head fast again.
“That’s fucking hot. We’re going to be your firsts, aren’t we, Catalina? You want us to be your firsts? You want me to fuck this ass while Cooper fucks that pussy and Don strokes his cock into your sweet, sexy mouth.”
“Oh God!” She screamed another release.
“And then I get to make love to you last. Just when you think you can’t go anymore, I’ll give you another orgasm,” Cody told her as he leaned down and nibbled her shoulder.
Jeremy moved around her, and Cooper moved from between her legs but kissed her on the mouth. She could taste her cream on his lips and then his tongue as he plunged it into her mouth. She reached up and grabbed hold of him, feeling so overwhelmed, but then he pulled back and Jeremy was there to take his place. Jeremy lifted her thighs over his shoulders as he sat in the chair in front of the table with her ass and pussy in his face.
He closed his eyes and inhaled.
“Fuck, you smell as sweet as honey.”